Weld original rear hub, or use SIL replacement?

Anything related to Lambrettas... ask tech questions, post helpful info, or just read and learn.
User avatar
dansuper
registered user
Posts: 106
Joined: Wed Aug 26, 2009 1:48 pm
Main scooter: 1963 LI 185
Location: Sydney, Australia.
Contact:

My original Innocenti rear hub is in decent nick, but one of the studs has at some point come loose and 'bored' its way out. I.e., there is now a distinctly larger hole for the stud than there should be, with no visible threads. And NO - I didn't do this, it was bought as a barn find... :roll:

Is it feasible to weld the hole and have it tapped for a replacement stud? Too risky?

I have just bought a genuine NOS SIL rear hub as a replacement. TBH, it's pretty rough - the casting around a few of the fins looks absolutely shocking. Is this normal? The rest of it seems ok, I suppose.

Opinions please.

Cheers,

Dan
User avatar
paulmgreen
registered user
Posts: 517
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2009 4:34 pm
Main scooter: Lambretta Group 4 Race 200
Location: Grantham
Contact:

Its certainly possible to have the hole rewelded by a competent welder...... but its a very uncommon thread to re-tap it and not many people would have one....


But to answer your question... yes it would certainly be possible.
YouTuve Vlog channel - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEhrgL ... vY_4Px2WTg

www.JPPLambretta.co.uk

Sponsors Replay Scooters JPPLambretta
User avatar
vegansydney
registered user
Posts: 223
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 8:52 am
Location: New York City
Contact:

You've got PM about a welder in Sydney.
oldbiker
registered user
Posts: 194
Joined: Wed Jun 17, 2009 6:21 pm
Location: Aintree
Contact:

Tapping odd metric threads.

To find the size of the tapping drill for any ISO metric or BA thread deduct the thread pitch from the diameter of the stud.
ie M6, dia 6x1.00 pitch > drill size is 5mm
M8, dia 8x1.25 pitch > drill size is 6.75mm
M10 fine, dia 10x1.00 pitch > drill size is 9mm
etc. etc.,

Buying very odd taps can be a pain, but I have always found SKF Dormer very helpfull even with left hand threads. send them a letter telling them you are an engineering student on a degree course and you need the tap for a project (lies :oops: ).

In theory it is possible to convert a high tensile bolt or stud into a single use tap.
Use an angle grinder with a fine cutting disk or a dremmel (etc) to cut a couple of flutes along the length of the stud,
then use a pedistal grinder to put a slight taper on the start of the stud.

It is difficult but possible, if you get it right it works ;) for a couple of uses.

As Paul says the welding is not too much of a problem.

Try getting the tap first.
ralph95
registered user
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 7:09 pm
Location: highbridge
Contact:

paulmgreen wrote:Its certainly possible to have the hole rewelded by a competent welder...... but its a very uncommon thread to re-tap it and not many people would have one....


But to answer your question... yes it would certainly be possible.
i do ;)
three wheels on my wagon
http://www.srpracetech.co.uk/
sponsored by www.opieoils.co.uk
User avatar
paulmgreen
registered user
Posts: 517
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2009 4:34 pm
Main scooter: Lambretta Group 4 Race 200
Location: Grantham
Contact:

Thats because you are a top engineer!!!!!!!!!!!!
YouTuve Vlog channel - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCEhrgL ... vY_4Px2WTg

www.JPPLambretta.co.uk

Sponsors Replay Scooters JPPLambretta
User avatar
dansuper
registered user
Posts: 106
Joined: Wed Aug 26, 2009 1:48 pm
Main scooter: 1963 LI 185
Location: Sydney, Australia.
Contact:

Thanks people - I think I'll prepare both hubs, if possible, and choose which one to use later on. Although it will be intersting to see how readily available the tap will be (in Sydney...).

As I said, just really disappointed with the casting qaulity of the SIL hub - and I believe this is a genuine one, too. Probably works fine but just looks so ugly; I'll have to build up the edges of a couple of the fins as they're missing so much metal from the mold. (?) :roll:

Dan
mickdale
registered user
Posts: 473
Joined: Tue Aug 04, 2009 8:40 pm
Contact:

are the changes in the mechanical properties of the heat affected zone in the cast alloy when electric arc welding (TIG/MMA/MIG) acceptable for the application?
shocky
registered user
Posts: 2139
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2009 12:33 pm
Location: cheltenham
Contact:

as a welder of 31 yrs i wouldnt weld an item like this for highway use , castings are an unknown quantity you never know what there made of unless you do a burn test and even then each batch can vary, as just mentiones the HAZ is an area were all sorts of things go on with reguard to grain structor, others will disagree but why scrimp on safety this part cost very little compaired to what your scooter is worth and more importantly yours and others lives should a failiour occure ............ if you have children ask yourself would you feel safe letting them get in a car or on a bike with a welded hub/wheel ?
We sleep soundly in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm
User avatar
dansuper
registered user
Posts: 106
Joined: Wed Aug 26, 2009 1:48 pm
Main scooter: 1963 LI 185
Location: Sydney, Australia.
Contact:

shocky wrote:as a welder of 31 yrs i wouldnt weld an item like this for highway use , castings are an unknown quantity you never know what there made of unless you do a burn test and even then each batch can vary, as just mentiones the HAZ is an area were all sorts of things go on with reguard to grain structor, others will disagree but why scrimp on safety this part cost very little compaired to what your scooter is worth and more importantly yours and others lives should a failiour occure ............ if you have children ask yourself would you feel safe letting them get in a car or on a bike with a welded hub/wheel ?
Thanks Shocky,

Appreciate the feedback. It is sometimes difficult to know the 'right' thing to do with stuff like this without any background knowledge.

The reason I bought the SIL hub was because my gut instinct told me it would be a bad idea to weld the original, but as you can see - as ever - there are always different opinions! Just trying to work out the best option, really.

Cheers,

Dan
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic
  • Information
  • Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests