mag flange gasket, is it needed
hi all,opinions sought,is a mag flange gasket necessary,or can i use hylomar blue or clear silicon to seal the face,reason is i'm going to run a af lightened flywheel and it is just missing the pick up with no gasket and might catch if i fit a gasket,dont want to go to the hassle of machining the magflange unless i really have to,cheers all.
-
- registered user
- Posts: 930
- Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 5:30 pm
- Main scooter: The Biriani Bullet
- Location: Brighton (well Hove actually)
- Contact:
AS no one else has had the decency to answer your question, I'll oblige. Yes, you could use silicone sealant. Be a bugger to get off later, but would do the job OK. But check that your crank web still has clearance from the mag flange (Oooohhhh, flange, I love that word) 

Compact Toolbox Flywheel Holder
what you really should do is have the face of the flange where the stator sits machined back by 1mm when using the af light flywheel set up
quite rude mate .. we all have lives out side of the forumdapper wrote:AS no one else has had the decency to answer your question
Its in bits scooter club: www.facebook.com/groups/132415046859320
cheers,will use some hylomar blue,non setting on the spigot,and some clear silicon on the gasket face,then should have a chance of getting it apart,hopefully not for a few years.
-
- registered user
- Posts: 930
- Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 5:30 pm
- Main scooter: The Biriani Bullet
- Location: Brighton (well Hove actually)
- Contact:
Smiley Ric, smileyRICSPEED wrote:what you really should do is have the face of the flange where the stator sits machined back by 1mm when using the af light flywheel set up
quite rude mate .. we all have lives out side of the forumdapper wrote:AS no one else has had the decency to answer your question

Compact Toolbox Flywheel Holder
-
- registered user
- Posts: 25
- Joined: Sat Apr 18, 2009 3:02 am
- Location: Raleigh, NC USA
- Contact:
I think the mating surface of your case and mag-flange will have a bearing on if you need a gasket or not.
I ran into a lot of problems getting a Spanish 200cc engine case to seal up at the mag flange, due to the matching face machined with concentric groves. The face on the flange was smooth. Never seen that on an Italian case. I had problems when pressure testing this engine, it was leaking around all three stator bolts, when I used Hylomar blue on both sides of a gasket. I minimized the leak down to one stator screw, and very minor at that (it could hold 2-3 lbs pressure for about 2 minutes) using a different, semi-hardening gasket maker on a new gasket. I don't look forward to taking this apart in the future. I went through three gaskets and a lot of goo to get it to this point.
On this engine, I could not seal it up without a gasket. Pressure testing with the piston at BDC was worse, it was not as bad with the piston at TDC. Although any leak is bad, I took the advice of a minor leak in the primary case pressure being tolerable, as opposed to a leak at the head, or manifolds, of which there were none.

IMAG0336 by starreem, on Flickr
I ran into a lot of problems getting a Spanish 200cc engine case to seal up at the mag flange, due to the matching face machined with concentric groves. The face on the flange was smooth. Never seen that on an Italian case. I had problems when pressure testing this engine, it was leaking around all three stator bolts, when I used Hylomar blue on both sides of a gasket. I minimized the leak down to one stator screw, and very minor at that (it could hold 2-3 lbs pressure for about 2 minutes) using a different, semi-hardening gasket maker on a new gasket. I don't look forward to taking this apart in the future. I went through three gaskets and a lot of goo to get it to this point.
On this engine, I could not seal it up without a gasket. Pressure testing with the piston at BDC was worse, it was not as bad with the piston at TDC. Although any leak is bad, I took the advice of a minor leak in the primary case pressure being tolerable, as opposed to a leak at the head, or manifolds, of which there were none.

IMAG0336 by starreem, on Flickr
-
- registered user
- Posts: 4823
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2011 9:50 pm
- Main scooter: Lambretta
- Location: Lanarkshire
- Contact:
RICSPEED wrote:what you really should do is have the face of the flange where the stator sits machined back by 1mm when using the af light flywheel set up
I did read somewhere that doing that might cause issues with the alignment of the pickup contacts with the magnet triggers.
If you are getting machining done it might be better to take a mm out of the inside of the flywheel to improve the clearance.
"Our dilemma is that we hate change and love it at the same time; what we really want is for things to remain the same but get better."
good point .. though i cant say if have had issues with mine at all
Its in bits scooter club: www.facebook.com/groups/132415046859320